In brief. It's all I have time for these days.
Watch #1: If you have actually been reading for awhile, you should recognize this one - I inherited it a few years ago. It was my grandmother's. My mother told me she had it (and that it was platinum and emeralds), that I would have it one day, and that she didn't know where it lay so she could give it to me "now." I found it after she passed when my sibs and I went through her two storage lockers, buried in the middle of a box, beneath a small TV, along with all the rest of my grandmother's jewelry. Not platinum but plated, not emeralds but glass. Don't care. It was a graduation present (I believe) to my Grandmama from her father. (Besides, the earrings that were also in the box - that only I wanted - were gold and about two carats of diamonds. I remember playing with them when I was a child and knocking out two of the tiny stones. I fixed them as an adult. What goes around, comes around.)
Watch #2: If you said this one, you are right! Found in a thrift shop, filthy and black in many places, with no band but with a label that said "silvertone", it couldn't have been appealing since it had been sitting awhile. I opened it, looked at the back ("Belais 18K") and said "yes, please!" The sapphires are likely synthetic, as was the habit of the day, but they actually look pretty real to me. (By the way - I cleaned overenthusiastically, with Barkeep's Friend, which is the only thing that would even
soften the black crud. NOT good for that lovely, characteristic swirl on the inside back cover. :( Sad.)
Watch #3: Not even gold plated. Probably sold at Woolworth's in the day. Still works, though, when none of the others do (except sporadically)! What does that tell you?
Watch #4: "14K Over Metal" (inside back) is just another way of saying gold plated, but with thicker plate. And over 1/2 ct of real diamonds. All that bling on a fairly cheap box. Really don't understand people from the first two decades of the 20th century.
Watch #5: 14K gold plated (even says so), synthetic sapphires. Very common. Easy to confuse with #2, huh? Actually, it looks better than #2 did when I found it so likely, if placed side-by-side then, this one would've won hands down. Might still, if anyone looks inside the real one.
So, how good were you?
Happy hunting!!